Jun. 21st, 2009

[public post] Could Alexander have taken over China?

Back when I was watching Alexander (and thus starting to be interested in Alexander the Great's exploits), I remember discussing with [info]tanithryudo that it was a good thing Alexander got stopped short at India, since otherwise he would have arrived in China just in time for the Warring States, and taken over China due to the internal squabbling at the time.

However, a closer look at the timeline suggests otherwise.

First, although China may be squabbling and divided at the time, each state had experience with warfare (and thus prepared for invasion) and had begun using crossbows. This is important because the crossbow was developed as a method to counter the nomadic tribes of the north, and thus specifically as an anti-cavalry weaponry. Because Alexander's warfare depended on elite cavalry to hammer down the opposing army, his methods wouldn't have taken the Chinese military completely by surprise.

Second, Alexander hadn't yet fully pushed through India and had to face Nanda Empire and Gangaridai Empire, with 4000 elephants between India and China. So by the time he got to China, his troops would probably be tired and exhausted. (Or acquired elephants.) So morale wise, China would have a slight upper hand (having only had to deal with neighboring states, instead of fighting all the way from Greece to India).

Third, if Alexander continued to advance as fast as he had in his earlier conquests, his army would have reached China before the Warring States (and Spring and Autumn era) and thus there will still exist a unified China to fight against Alexander's forces.

So maybe China's forces would have been able to hold up against Alexander's army. Who knows these things, right?


Edit:
Oh right, forgot to mention, China also had Art of War on their side. (Untranslated!)
Posted at 01:54 pm

Jun. 20th, 2009

[public post] *giggles*

Waiting is Hell

Watching Charon being chewed out by Hades and Alexander and Hephaestion being generic stubborn blockheads cracks me up. It's certainly a comedic take on a tragedy. And just think of the chaos Alexander is going to cause in the afterlife! The Underworld is soooo going to be conquered soon, especially now that he has the likes of Achilles and Herakles in his command! (And let's face it, if any of those Greek heroes are going to lead an army, it's going to have to be Alexander. :P)


On the Sunny Banks of the Cydnus

Alexander is a horrible patient, Hephaestion an exasperated nursemaid, and the Companion Cavalry looking for blood from a poor, poor physician. I'd try to explain why the story rocks but a quote from the story serves that purpose so much the better.
"He went for a swim!" howled one.

"He said it was hot!" bawled another.

"How can we go on without our Alexander! – " And the rest was jumbled in an anguished cacophony.

"You're not telling me anything useful!" Critodemus fumed.
XD
Posted at 10:08 pm

November 2009

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

About

For best viewing results, please use Firefox 3.0 or above when browsing this journal.
RSS Atom
Powered by InsaneJournal